skip to Main Content

ANY FRESHER, YOU'D BE WET.

Fresh and delicious, from salads and sushi to Italian and traditional American.

Full food and drink menu available for online ordering. Pleace your order and pick it up at Surf’s Out in 40 minutes, or we can deliver to Kismet, Saltaire or Fair Harbor.

You can not drive to Surf’s Out, as Fire Island roads are closed to cars.
But there are lots of other ways to get here!

Main Menu

We're just Getting Started

Wings

    • 15.00

Served with Bleu Cheese and celery

Lucky 13 Oysters

    • 12.00
      6 pieces
    • 21.00
      12 pieces

Local as local gets

Soup

    • 12.00

Crab and corn

Black Bean & Avocado Dip

    • 16.00

Ancho chili sauce, yuca chips

Crispy Fried Calamari

    • 15.00

House made marinara, lemon garlic aioli

Bangs Island Mussels

    • 14.00

House made marinara, white wine garlic, fra diavolo

Crispy Chicken Bacon Ranch Flat Bread

    • 15.00

Golden fried chicken, crisp bacon, melted cheddar, ranch drizzle

Margarita Flat Bread

    • 15.00

Trimmed Beach Grass

Classic Caesar Salad

    • 14.00

Crisp romaine, shaved parmesan, garlic croutons, creamy dressing

Organic Mixed Greens

    • 15.00

Cucumber, tomato, red onion, granny smith apples, creamy balsamic dressing

Watermelon Feta

    • 16.00

Watercress, roasted heirloom tomatoes, mint yogurt, balsamic glaze

"Sandy"wich

All sandwiches and burgers served with fries.

Southern Fried Chicken Sammi

    • 18.00

Crispy fried chicken thigh, cilantro jalapeno slaw, melted pepper jack

Prime Surf's Out Burger

    • 20.00

Lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle

Burrata Burger

    • 23.00

Charred prime burger, lettuce, tomato bacon jam, burrata mozzarella

Maine Lobster Roll

    • 26.00

Toasted bun, warm buttery lobster OR chilled lobster salad

Charred Steak Sandwich

    • 21.00

Mixed greens, red wine jam, pickled tomatoes

Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

    • 20.00

Crisp romaine, grilled chicken, parmesan

Entrees

Chicken Fingers

    • 15.00

With honey Dijon dipping sauce and fries

Penne Alla Vodka

    • 20.00

Whole peeled plum tomato cream sauce shaved Parmesan cheese flamed Absolut vodka

Fish & Chips

    • 24.00

Golden fried cod, crisp chips, tartar sauce

Seafood Fra Diavolo

    • 30.00

Mussels, clams, shrimp, calamari, linguini

Grilled Chicken Bruschetta

    • 22.00

Tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil, garlic crostinis

Pan Roasted Shrimp & Zoodles

    • 28.00

Shrimp, plum tomatoes, roasted garlic lemon broth, zoodles (zucchini noodles)

Grilled Salmon

    • 26.00

Chilled wild rice, farro, quinoa, dried cherries, soy Dijon vinaigrette

Survival Kits

The Bucket

    • 40.00

5 beers 20 wings

The Picnic

    • 100.00

Bottle of Rose or Sauvignon Blanc, GIANT salad with lobster meat, 4 forks.

Sushi

Appetizers

Edamame

    • 7.00

Yummy Balls

    • 8.00

Crunch, spicy tuna, rice ball, spicy mayo (3 pieces)

Seaweed Salad

    • 7.00

Shrimp Tempura Appetizer

    • 13.00

5 pieces

Sushi / Sashimi

Sushi 1 Piece / Sashimi 2 Pieces

Tuna

    • 4.00
      Sushi
    • 4.00
      Sashimi

Salmon

    • 4.00
      Sushi
    • 4.00
      Sashimi

White Tuna

    • 4.00
      Sushi
    • 4.00
      Sashimi

Grilled Eel

    • 4.00
      Sushi
    • 4.00
      Sashimi

Cooked Shrimp

    • 3.00
      Sushi
    • 3.00
      Sashimi

Classic Rolls

California Roll

    • 9.00
      Classic
    • 9.00
      Hand

crab, cucumber, avocado

Crunchy Spicy Crab

    • 10.00
      Classic
    • 10.00
      Hand

Crunch Spicy Tuna

    • 10.00
      Classic
    • 10.00
      Hand

Shrimp Tempura

    • 12.00
      Classic
    • 12.00
      Hand

Specialty Rolls

Fish Finder

    • 23.00

(IN) shrimp tempura, avocado
(OUT) spicy tuna, crunch spicy mayo, teriyaki

Pink Bikini

    • 23.00

(IN) crunch spicy salmon, avocado, cucumber
(OUT) sliced salmon, teriyaki, spicy mayo

Red Bikini

    • 23.00

(IN) crunch spicy tuna, avocado, cucumber
(OUT) sliced tuna, teriyaki, spicy mayo

Miru Mountain

    • 23.00

(IN) crunch spicy tuna, avocado
(OUT) crunch spicy crab salad, mango aioli

Lobster Out

    • 24.00

(IN) crunch shrimp tempura, avocado
(OUT) Lobster salad, spicy mayo, wasabi mayo

Poke Bowls

Surf Yutari Sushi

    • 23.00

Includes edamame, avocado, crunch, lettuce, sesame seed

Beverages

Sodas, Etc.

Fountain Soda

    • 2.50

coke, diet coke, unsweetened iced tea, ginger ale

Gatorade

    • 3.00

Bottled Water

    • 2.00

Beers

Miller Highlife

    • 5.00

Bud

    • 6.00

Michelob Ultra

    • 6.00

Landshark

    • 6.00

Miller Light

    • 6.00

Red Stripe

    • 8.00

Montauk Summer Ale

    • 8.00

Montauk Wave Chaser IPA

    • 8.00

Heineken Light

    • 8.00

Brooklyn Summer Ale

    • 8.00

Sapporo

    • 8.00

St. Pauli Girl Non-Alcoholic

    • 8.00

White Wine

Mezza Bubbly Prosecco

    • 11.00
      Glass
    • 30.00
      Bottle

Albertoni Chardonnay, California

    • 11.00
      Glass
    • 30.00
      Bottle

Mezzacorona Pinot Grigio, Italy

    • 11.00
      Glass
    • 30.00
      Bottle

Echo Bay Sauvignon Blanc, New Zealand

    • 11.00
      Glass
    • 30.00
      Bottle

J Lohr Riesling, California

    • 11.00
      Glass
    • 30.00
      Bottle

Pomelo Rose, California

    • 11.00
      Glass
    • 30.00
      Bottle

Red Wine

Mezzacorona Pinot Noir, Italy

    • 11.00
      Glass
    • 30.00
      Bottle

Albertoni Cabernet Sauvignon, California

    • 11.00
      Glass
    • 30.00
      Bottle

Lignum Blend, Italy

    • 11.00
      Glass
    • 30.00
      Bottle

Sangria

White Peach Sangria

    • 11.00
      Glass
    • 30.00
      Pitcher

Red Mixed Berry Sangria

    • 11.00
      Glass
    • 30.00
      Pitcher

Online Ordering Hours:

Sun, Sat12:00 PM-6:30 PMMon-Friclosed